Wow, this must be embarrassing
Wednesday, June 20, 2007
Like the privately held Bay area lender who shall hereafter remain nameless (don't ask), DataQuick President Marshall Prentice must not be liking what he sees when he Googles himself.
At first, a typographical error was suspected but, as it turns out, the spelling is correct. A search on "Marshall Prentice" returns a late-2005, not-so-flattering post from this blog in the number one spot.Regarding Southern California, DataQuick President Marshall Prentice seems particularly intent on shaping public opinion about what the future holds:
This post goes on at great length about a series of DataQuick articles, calculating "typical" mortgage payments, and a few other topics."The big question is still whether or not the real estate market will end this cycle with a crash, or with a soft landing. Right now the latter scenario is still the most likely. Home values have doubled in the past four years and almost all, if not all, of those gains are here to stay," said Marshall Prentice, DataQuick president.
So, that second sentence is passable as sound analysis of the current situation - no evidence of anything crashing yet. But that third sentence is really very prescient, no? Divine omniscience? Didn't know that you had that in you Marshall - how else to explain stating as fact that an early 1990s style pull back in price levels is out of the question?
It's hard to believe that this is from 20 months ago and it still comes up as number one - it looks like Marshall needs a stronger "web presence" to knock stuff like this off of the first page.
That's one bad thing (or good thing, depending on how you look at it) about blogs and especially those hosted by a company such as Google where disk space is essentially unlimited - this stuff hangs around forever.
Admittedly, using DataQuick's median home price figures, Marshall's "almost all, if not all of those gains are here to stay" prediction is far from being wrong - SoCal median home prices are still rising, though you'd have a hard time convincing sellers of this.
The problem is that the housing slowdown is going on much, much longer than any of the optimists ever envisioned and the chances of that guarantee holding up fade a little more with each monthly report from DataQuick.
Ironically, in the most recent report on May sales, Marshall himself wonders why prices haven't fallen further."Sales have been dropping now for the last 20 months. The first part of that was just coming off the frenzy of 2004 and 2005 and didn't put that much downward pressure on prices. The sales declines of the last half year, though, will have more of an effect on prices. It's remarkable they haven't come down more than they have," said Marshall Prentice, DataQuick president.
2 comments:
Median prices are still rising in some areas because the bottom end of the market has fallen off while the top end is still intact. You are comparing apples and oranges.
Marshall Prentice was born in Scotland and he's lived in Delhi, London, Vancouver BC, and now San Diego. He has a PhD in particle physics (DataQuick's parent company is a Canadian Aerospace firm). He has worked for MacDonald Dettwiler, DataQuick's parent company, for over 30 years.
Typical mortgages include those closed many years ago. DataQuick, more specifically DataQuick News, has a database that goes back to 1988 and it tracks each property by history. They can run reports that only show those mortgages that are still open. In the open mortgage universe, one can model for such things as variable rate and then calculate payments. Therefore it is inaccurate to extrapolate "typical mortgage" using the most recent 5 years' data. I don’t recall reading, “the typical mortgage for a homeowner purchasing an $X home with X% down”. Rather, they are talking about the typical mortgage overall.
Finally, resale prices have become a function of the buyer’s access to capital. Higher priced homes are selling better than entry level homes because the buyer has more money to put down. Because entry end purchases are being suppressed by the credit crunch, more homes are selling in the high end, by comparison. The median moves up because the lower end is being more heavily impacted by the credit market.
The liquidity issues facing the economy are dire and they dragging the entire economy into recession. Government, homeowners and business are all competing for capital. Banks won't lend to each other and that is constricting the flow of capital. It is a bad situation.
Post a Comment