Inflation, Zimbabwe Style
Tuesday, March 13, 2007
With two important reports on inflation due later this week, a look at some recent developments in Zimbabwe might be useful, just to put rising prices in the U.S. into better perspective - to see what the worst case scenario might look like.
As you'll recall, Zimbabwe is a South African nation currently experiencing "hyperinflation". According to Wikipedia, after hundreds of millions of dollars were spent on a recent war and efforts to develop a market-oriented economy were abandoned, inflation has skyrocketed from an annual rate of 32 percent in 1998 to a high of 1,730 percent just last week.
With an unemployment rate of 80 percent, President Robert Mugabe blames foreign governments for meddling, while the international community argues that the country's difficulties stem from Mugabe's controversial program to seize land from white farmers.
For ordinary citizens, the turmoil has real consequences.
Late last month came word that life for young Nelson Banya is full of challenges, not the least of which is figuring out how much things will cost with each new day. Not to be confused with The Economist's Big Mac Index (where, curiously, the Zimbabwe currency does not appear) Nelson finds a "Lunchbox Index" to be a useful indicator of declining purchasing power.Last August, when the central bank introduced new banknotes, having lopped off three zeros, 1,000 Zimbabwe dollars could provide a decent packed sandwich; a couple of slices of bread, some eggs and even a slice of ham on good days.
Amid high unemployment, demand appears to be strong for one job - grocery store clerk. It seems that changing prices tags on a daily basis keeps many of them from restocking shelves.
Now 1,000 Zimbabwe dollars will buy only two eggs. Bread, which cost about 250 dollars 12 months ago, now costs 1,000 dollars.
Cash machines have stopped dispensing 1,000 dollar bills and now issue 10,000 dollar notes.
The bundles of banknotes keep growing. Where 100,000 dollars would go a long way in meeting my grocery needs for a month last August, I need five times that amount now.
In this story from earlier this month, the government announced that new bills were being put into circulation to help combat the inflation.Zimbabwe's central bank introduced two new bank notes on Thursday as it battles a four figure rate of inflation that is rapidly eroding the value of the local currency.
Lopping off zeros from the currency failed to achieve the desired objective of halting price increases. Similarly, issuing larger denomination notes helped to alleviate back strain while lugging around cash, but has no other discernible impact.
The new 50,000 dollar note, worth around 200 US dollars, and the 5,000 bill are the latest additions to a series of temporary notes that were introduced three years ago to ease critical cash shortages.
The temporary notes are only valid for a short period of time. The current ones expire in July.
The central bank said in an advert placed in the local press that it was "introducing the new 5,000-dollar and 50,000-dollar bearer cheques from March 1, 2007 for your convenience."
A two month strike by doctors recently came to a peaceful conclusion. This report from the LA Times details how the government reached a deal with doctors, nurses and paramedics to boost their wages to help them keep up.Government doctors stopped work in December, demanding an 8,000% wage increase, with the government offering a 300% hike.
Well, it's probably going to get worse than just street protests.
Before the strike, state doctors earned currency worth about $224 at the official exchange rate but about $7 on the black market.
The president of the Hospital Doctors Assn., Kuda Nyamutukwa, confirmed that doctors had agreed a pay deal with the government but declined to give details of the new wages.
...
Analysts have warned that rising discontent over the economic meltdown in Zimbabwe could trigger street protests against Mugabe's government.
Yesterday, The Economist reported that those opposing Mr. Mugabe are being tortured and beaten as the economy "sinks deeper into the mud".
Throughout all of this, the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe continues to operate. Their website appears to be in working order and reports are available to get a better feel for how monetary policy is being conducted.
In fact, the central bank recently released their semi-annual monetary policy statement that anyone can download and have a look at. Here's one of the more interesting charts.
The report is an interesting read. Bankers state their current condition in a very matter-of-fact way, discussing the challenges ahead and ways that progress can be made.
Some are predicting that inflation will get worse before it gets better - 4,000 percent is the figure now frequently mentioned.
12 comments:
Tim,
This week laundry charge for a trouser was increased from $2.75 to $3.25 in zip code 95014 ...
Over one year this has increased from $2.25 to $3.25
Hope this helps.
I would have to say Zimbabwe is a someone silly example. Perhaps a European nation with 10% unemployment might be a little better example? Are we as corrupt as Italy now?
Has anyone else noticed how many people order water with restaurant meals these days?
It used to be that you wouldn't think anything about adding an extra dollar to your lunch by having a soda, but now it's closer to $2 and the food is closer to $10.
This probably qualifies as substitution in the eyes of the BLS and a steep decline in some food category within the consumer price index since water is free.
Where I used to work, in the company cafeteria, it would crack me up when someone visiting from out of town would buy the entree, a soda, and a cookie and the total would be over nine dollars. They'd give the cashier a ten dollar bill and look at a few coins they got back and wonder what the heck was going on.
Personally I order water because I don't want to spend the calories. A coke is about 160 calories for a 12-ounce serving. It could be that more people are ordering water (notice that most places now offer bottled water, too) because the obesity scare is finally having an effect.
Also, I think people are appalled at paying $2 a can for something that you can get at a grocery store for less than a quarter.
This just in....
Zimbabwe party leader taken to hospital
Zimbabwe's most prominent opposition leader, his face swollen and a large gash on his head, was taken to a hospital Tuesday under police guard after appearing briefly in court along with about 50 activists arrested while trying to attend a prayer meeting.
Don't know what Zimbabwe has to do with 'Ol Greenie.... maybe that's why you are thinking of a name change.... because of smartalecks like me who remind you when you stray.... unless there's a Zimbabwe/Greenspan connection????
I don’t think you can compare Zim to the US. Although there is mismanagement here it doesn’t even touch on the level of incompetence and the total lack of economic intelligence there. For example with the land redistribution, weather you disagree with it or not, they simply took high yielding farms and handed them over to people with no farming experience , save for subsistence farming, and no capital. Considering that farming was by far the biggest sector, this would be like the US handing over all its financial institutions to the Indian reservations with high school diplomas. Although they probably would do a better job of it than those new land owners, it wouldn’t take long before the sector had some serious issues. Combine this with rampant corruption and …. What surprises me is that it took as long as it did to get here.
To those who don't understand the connection between Zimbabwe and Greenspan / USA I only feel pity.
No what I meant to say is get your head out of your ass! Jeez
If the US didn't have the world's reserve currency, and if we didn't have all this wealth created by our ancestors to squander, we would be *exactly* like Zimbabwe.
Pretty soon, we will lose reserve currency status, and all that inherited wealth will be gone.
I'm converting my currency to gold/silver and getting it out of the country ASAP.
>I don’t think you can compare Zim to
>the US. Although there is
>mismanagement here it doesn’t even
>touch on the level of incompetence
>and the total lack of economic
>intelligence there.
President Mugabe is constantly comparing his Country with the US.
He justifies Zimbabwean election irregularities by pointing to allegations of vote rigging in Miami.
He justifies his crackdown on opposition members as a "War on Terror"
Hey, Apollo, by all means leave the country if you want. Just don't go whining to us when you can't find a decent job anywhere else because their governments won't allow owners to fire non-productive employees.
And don't whine about how their markets are inextricable tied to ours and go down hard when ours go down soft.
And don't whine about how many jobs they lose to new automation technology being invented and perfected everyday in the USA.
Frankly, having the world's benchmark currency makes little difference. Our nation has weathered the toughest times in history and come out of it shaken, but not beaten. We've been the world's leader in technological innovation for well over 100 years. We have more 'firsts' to our name than most other countries have 'seconds'. And we have consistently outperformed the rest of the developed world in cases of employment, individual wealth, and property ownership.
Surely this can't all be because of the 18-year reign of Greenspan. I mean, can you really justify blaming him for things that happened before he was part of the Fed? Did we win WW2 bnecause of Alan Greenspan? Did Greenspan cause the 1929 overspeculation crash and the subsequent Great Depression? Was Greenspan a benefactor of the 'Teapot Dome' scandal?
Listen, I know that a lot of today's problems can be traced to ol'Greenie, but some of the doomsayers who post here need to get a grip, or failing that, follow in the footsteps of Apollo and leave.
Then we can get on with the serious business of ruling the world. (j/k)
"Then we can get on with the serious business of ruling the world. (j/k)"
Hey wait a minute if we're going to be an Empire rule the world is part of the script. Just like every other empire until it goes horribly wrong.
So lets get on with it, "To Infinity and Beyond!"
One thing I don't get is how banana republics get into these types of problems.
With an excess of good economists and other talent including consulting firms, why don't these governments just hire a couple of economists or firms to help them figure out a plan?
Seems simple to me.
Post a Comment