Wikinvest Wire

The recession is over?

Wednesday, July 15, 2009

In the spirit of equal time for disparate opinions, the dour outlook from Mort Zuckerman posted just a short time ago is followed by this uplifting view from Daniel Gross at Slate:

Could our long national nightmare be over? The economic contraction, this Great Recession, began in December 2007, and there's no apparent end in sight. As the unemployment rate has spiked, analysts have thrown cold water on Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke's March sighting of "green shoots." The stock market's spring rally has fizzled.

But in this season of doubt, I'm prepared to declare that the recession is really, most probably over. Why? Well, it's not because the economists surveyed by the Wall Street Journal believe it'll end in this quarter. (These guys wouldn't know an economic inflection point if it hit them upside the head. All through 2008, when the economy was contracting, they projected growth for the year.)

No, two of the best and most objective forecasters, who are not connected to investment banks or to the CNBC noise machine, have recently called the upturn. Macroeconomic Advisers, the St. Louis-based consulting firm that compiles a monthly GDP index, reported to its clients Monday that while second-quarter GDP was tracking at negative 0.1 percent (recession), the third quarter was tracking at 2.4 percent growth.
Uh-oh. Here comes the "this recession is just like all the previous ones" argument where we can all just dismiss the profound, if somewhat slow to develop, changes underway in the consumer sector and the depths of the labor market troubles.

Do so at your own peril, as they seem anxious to do at the ECRI.
The folks at the Economic Cycles Research Institute agree enthusiastically. It's not because they've detected green pea shoots in Central Park. Rather, it's because we've seen the three P's, says Lakshman Achuthan, managing director at ECRI, which has been studying business cycles for decades and was one of the few outfits to call the last two recessions with any degree of accuracy.

The economic data that get the most play in the news— unemployment, retail sales—are coincident or lagging indicators and historically have not revealed much about directional changes in the economy. ECRI's proprietary methodology breaks down indicators into a long-leading index, a weekly leading index, and a short-leading index. "We watch for turning points in the leading indexes to anticipate turning points in the business cycle and the overall economy," says Achuthan. It's tough to recognize transitions objectively "because so often our hopes and fears can get in the way." To prevent exuberance and despair from clouding vision, ECRI looks for the three P's: a pronounced rise in the leading indicators; one that persists for at least three months; and one that's pervasive, meaning a majority of indicators are moving in the same direction.

The long-leading index—which goes back to the 1920s and doesn't include stock prices but does include measures related to credit, housing, productivity, and profits—hits bottom and starts to climb about six months before a recession ends. The weekly leading index calls directional shifts about three to four months in advance. And the short-leading index, which includes stock prices and jobless claims, is typically the last to turn up.

All three are now flashing green...
At this point, it's probably important to remind everyone of the name of the book Daniel Gross had published a couple years ago: Pop! Why Bubbles Are Great For The Economy.

Publisher: HarperBusiness; 1 edition (May 8, 2007)

Bookmark and Share


marku said...

The recession might be about over, but who really cares? Over the past 20 years, we have perfected an economy which in exiting a recession, creates no good jobs (or net none at all, over the last business cycle). And, when there is economic "growth" in GDP, all the benefits accrue to the top 1%, while everyone below gets eaten alive by the "volatile food and energy sector" inflation.
And don't even get me started about health care inflation.

Bottom line--Sure the "recession" will end. But for 99% of us, it won't make any difference.

Anonymous said...

Maybe the only difference it will make is a different set of people will get hurt. Instead of the unemployed getting hurt by the recession, all those who are still employed will get hurt by galloping inflation, especially in basic needs.

Hooray, I love the new economy! Heads the masses lose, tails the masses lose. The choice between recession and inflation is becoming as bad as the choice between donkeys and elephants.

Tim said...

From New Deal Democrat:

Tim, keep in mind that ECRI and its indicators *WERE* around for the Great Depression, and the other pre-World War 2 deflationary busts.

- Peace, NDD

  © Blogger template Newspaper by 2008

Back to TOP